Reviews, Commentary and Discussions on Photography
TwitterFacebookYouTube

Camera Flash Accessories on the Cheap – Automatic Exposure Remote Flash

Many of the major camera brands are now offering expensive wireless flash systems with TTL automatic exposure. With these systems camera flash units are setup in positions remote from the camera and a special master flash on the camera controls them all. The master unit tells them when to fire and how much light to put out.

Remote TTL flash systems are nice and slick but they are expensive. Each flash can cost hundreds of dollars plus there is the cost of stands, umbrellas or soft boxes and more. But what if we could achieve something similar without a huge outlay of cash? We can build such a system and it could cost less than a single flash unit of the branded variety.

First I’d like to get us all on the same page about what to expect. There is no free lunch here, but what we will discuss is a viable alternative for many photographers. This system is a blend of old technology and new and will likely involve purchasing some used equipment.

Further, the expensive branded systems have all of their remote flashes set and controlled from the camera position master unit; our on-the-cheap system will require the photographer to alter settings on each flash manually. This system is not TTL; the camera’s meter isn’t used at all to achieve exposure.

Many years ago Automatic Flash was the preferred system of flash exposure. The flash was mounted on the camera and exposure was determined using a scale and calculator on the back of the flash. After using the calculator settings were made to the camera and flash. A sensor on the front of the flash measured the flash output and quenched it when the proper amount of light had been emitted. It was a simple system and it worked very well for decades.

Our flash system is made up of three parts. First we need three flash units and they must be Automatic Flash-capable. It’s time to get those Vivitar 283 and 285 flashes out of mothballs. They are ideal for this system. If you can’t find yours try buying them off your buddy, they generally bring less than $50 each. Key here is to find flash units with Guide Numbers at or greater than 89 feet at 100ISO.

Next we need a set of flash triggers. For the triggers I like the Promaster 4-Channel trigger. Here is the fun part: The expensive branded TTL multi-flash systems only work when they are all in line of sight. However the Promaster 4-Channel trigger is radio frequency operated. Line of sight not required! Our system will need one trigger and three receivers with a total cost of under $100.

Last, we need some stands or tripods to hold the three flash units. Here we have lots of latitude, anything that has a 1/4X 20 threaded post will do. Look for supports that can hold the light anywhere from a foot off the floor to several feet above the subject. If the photographer chooses to use standard light stands they will cost about $25 each.

That’s it, for about $300 we now have a three-flash remote lighting setup. All that’s left is learning how to use it!

It will take some practice to develop the skills needed to use this system, but it won’t be terribly hard. Most of the skills will be involved with learning lighting patterns and there are dozens of books on the subject. What concerns us however is discovering the settings we need to use with our new system.

Let’s assume that we have a basic three-light setup: a fill light near camera position, a main light to one side of the subject and a hair light on the other side. As a starting point make sure that all flashes are the same distance from the subject.The first thing we need to do is determine the setting for our main light. We use the calculator on the back of the flash and find the correct aperture for our camera. We set the flash sensor for this as well. Next we set the camera at the calculator’s f-stop and the shutter speed to 1/90 second. Now we have a good exposure setting for our main light.

Next we take the settings we calculated for our main light and set our fill flash’s sensor to expose one stop less. This is a little counterintuitive because we are setting the shut off point of the flashes not the exposure point. If the main light is set for f/5.6 our fill light could be set one stop less – f/4.0 for example. We want one stop less light so the fill flash has to turn off faster than the main flash. The third flash, the hair light, we want to have one stop more exposure so we set it to shut off at f/8.0.

We are ready for a test. The camera shutter is tripped and the main flash pumps out enough light to expose at f/5.6, the correct exposure for the subject. The fill light has been fooled to turn off at an exposure of f/4.0 so it will supply one less stop of flash than the main. The hair light has been told to expose for f/8.0 so it will pump out one stop more light than the main flash.

The result will be a subject with a well exposed light from the side, the frontally positioned fill light to lessen shadows across the face, and a brighter hair light to offer separation of the subject from the background. The first attempts may look stark and unforgiving, but practice in positioning the lights will pay off well in eliminating the problem.

It will take some practice to determine the correct working distances between flash and subject. Further, if light modifiers such as umbrellas or soft boxes are used we need to make sure that the flash unit’s sensor is still able to “see” the subject. I would strongly suggest that all three flash units be the same brand and model; it will help reduce any inconsistencies from one use to the next.

Experiment with different combination of f-stop settings on the flashes. Try bouncing the flash to reduce the stark quality of the light or shoot through a handkerchief. Once the photographer has mastered the basics of this three-light system it can serve as a useful skill for years.

Digital Camera Flash – The Nikon CLS Flash System

There was a time when I hauled around a studio lighting set to every wedding that I shot. The set was power-pack based and weighed in at close to forty pounds. I had stands, umbrellas, softboxes, grids, snoots and reflectors – just about anything you could want for on location shooting. What I lacked was a pack mule to haul it all around for me.

Then several years ago a friend turned me on to the Nikon CLS flash system. I had already seen pictures that she had taken at the last wedding she shot and the images were nice and bright so I was predisposed to like the system. Then she showed me the small bag her lighting gear fit into. That’s all it took to make me a wannabe convert.

The Nikon Creative Lighting System (CLS) consists of Nikon Speedlights and whatever stands and light management tools you care to take with you. The rig I use for demos has three SB-900 Speedlights, stands, and three umbrellas. With this comparatively lightweight setup I’m ready to shoot group shots as large as six or seven people.

Before we delve too deeply into the overview we need to be aware the the CLS feature is not available with every Nikon flash and camera. CLS features are only possible with Nikon branded equipment.

Nikon’s CLS system provides communication between the Commander unit (master) and one or more groups of remote (slave) flashes. The system is in two parts: The Commander unit which can be an SB Speedlight, the built-in flash of select cameras, or Nikon’s SU-800 non-flash command unit. The remote Nikon Speedlights are the other part of the system.

To date, these Nikon cameras offer Commander Mode with their built-in pop-up flashes: D700, D300 series, D200, D90, D80, D70s, and D7000. Nikon Speedlights that support CLS are: SB-800, SB-900, SB-700, SB-600, and the SB-R200.

To use CLS with a camera lacking a compatible pop-up flash (or no pop-up flash at all) we use the SU-800 Commander unit or SB-900 Speedlight. The older SB-800 Speedlight has a Commander Mode as well but this model has been discontinued for a while.

After assembling a CLS compatible kit it’s time to get familiar with the concept of remote, wireless TTL flash. The technical part about how it all works we are going to leave alone, right now we are interested in using it not taking it apart to see what makes it tick.

The key to using any system is working within its limitations. In the case of Nikon’s CLS flash all units, Commander and all remotes, must be in line of sight. We can’t stick a flash out of sight and around a corner and expect our Commander to control it.

As we setup our Speedlights on location we turn them on, select a receiving channel and assign them to a Group. We can have up to three groups of flashes (four with the correct flashes and commander) and each Group can have an unlimited number of flashes in it.
This is the fun part. Once our remote flashes are set inj place and assigned to a Group we can control their behavior from the camera or camera mounted flash Commander mode. For example we can have all of the Speedlights in Group A dialed in as the main light, they will provide enough light as determined by the camera’s meter. Group B we can choose to use as fill flash and we can set all Group B Speedlights to be 2/3 stop less than the metered exposure. Finally for Group C we want to use them for hair lighting so we set this group to be just over one stop more than the camera’s metered exposure.

All of these settings are made from the camera position on the Commander unit. There is no running back and forth to each remote Speedlight. We are all set so we take the shot. Uh oh, our fill light was too strong so using the Commander we dial Group B down another half stop. That simple, auto-exposure TTL flash control cannot be accomplished with a studio lighting set.

What has just been described is a basic three-light CLS operation, but there is so much more to it. Groups can be set to entirely different flash modes. For example Group A can be TTL while Group B is set for Manual. In short, Nikon’s CLS can create an unlimited number of flash configurations and exposure patterns.

For even more flexibility CLS offers several channels for operation too. At another wedding I attended there was a three-photographer team shooting the reception. One photographer was setup to shoot formals, another roamed for party pictures while the third was shooting portraits of the guests. All three photographers were shooting in the same room and since each shooting venue could be assigned a channel there were no instances of one Commander unit setting off the other guy’s flashes.

By the way, we haven’t even mentioned that since Nikon’s CLS is based on battery operated Speedlights the whole system can be used outdoors, miles from the nearest AC outlet.

In conclusion: Nikon’s CLS flash has a lot to offer in convenience, portability and exposure control. The CLS capable Speedlights and cameras can be arranged to suit almost any need. While CLS provides unprecedented control over flash it does come with a significant price tag. The Nikon SB-900 Speedlight costs just a little more than a comparably powered Bowens moonlight. However the Bowens light has no TTL exposure capabilities. The upside is that a CLS Speedlight system can be acquired one flash at a time.